Captain Robert Freymann
Captain Thomas Hurlbut
Royal Navy Squadron on the Lakes
October 2nd, 1813
Dear Captain Freymann
I am off to the interior, in effect to complete the trip to Amherstburg shipyard that I began nearly a month ago, but this time, to do it entirely overland as the sea route is occupied by the US Navy’s Lake Erie Squadron. I am detailed to salvage what is possible from the yard and bring it back to Burlington where the Commodore will decide whether to begin the process of creating another shipyard to build a new squadron on the upper lakes, or use it to enhance and re-enforce the Lake Ontario Squadron.
And it is certainly necessary to do the latter as we have had another encounter with US Commodore Chauncey and his fleet. I will now tell you the story..
In pursuit of my mission, I shipped out as a supernumerary aboard HMS Royal George (20), a vessel I had not been aboard for several months. She was the largest vessel on the lakes at the commencement of the war, a flush decked ship-sloop launched in 1809 to counter the US brig Oneida (18) commissioned the same year. I am well familiar with her as I had been a member of the Provincial Marine before the Royal Navy came to the lakes to take over the naval affairs here earlier this year. Pierced for 20 guns, originally to be all 32 pdr carronades, she now boasts a battery of 2-68 pdr carronades, and 2-18 pdr long guns as well as the 16 remaining 32 pdr carronades. She’s 96 feet on deck making her roughly the size of the Cruizer class brigs so fancied by the Admiralty. She’s a sweet sailor, very maneuverable, but Spartan in appointments, no fancy scrollwork or even stern galleries. All in all, she’s a no nonsense warship and now that she’s manned by proper sailormen of the Service, a “tough ‘un!”
Repairs had been effected on the squadron after the encounter with Commodore Isaac Chauncey off of the River Genesee on the 11th where a calm had nearly done for them. The Americans had the weather gauge but the light wind did not allow them to maneuver quickly. With the US schooners using sweeps in an attempt to close, Commodore Sir James Yeo towed his squadron using ships’ boats and kept the distance to long cannon shot where only the long guns could be effectively employed. Eventually, a breeze came up and Sir James was able to sail the Squadron away from the trap against the US shore and made his way back to Kingston. It was at this time that Sir James decided he would only battle Chauncey when there was sufficient wind to close and render our carronades effective.
At 6 AM on the 28th of September, in rising north easterly wind south west of York, the American squadron was sighted about 12 miles southeast of us. Sir James’ flagship is the ship-sloop HMS Wolfe, rated 22 and equipped with 18-32 pdr carronades, 2-68 pdr carronades and 2-12 pdr long guns. She’s almost 6 feet longer than the George and somewhat faster. Royal George was second in line followed by brig Lord Melville (14), 72 feet on deck, sloop Earl of Moira (16), 71 feet on deck, schooner Lord Beresford (12), 73 feet on deck and the schooner Sir Sydney Smith (12).
The squadron turned north east by north to try to take the weather gauge but could not weather Gibraltar Point so tacked, and headed south, still in line of battle. Chauncey, also in line ahead and heading north, then wore around and headed south by west on a slowly converging course.
The flagship of the American Squadron is the corvette General Pike (26), 145 feet between perpendiculars, making it bigger than all of the US 32 gun frigates and even the 36 gun USS New York! That, coupled with her battery of 24 pdr long guns make her a difficult opponent. She was hampered however, by having to tow the schooner Asp (3) into action.
Following Pike and Asp was the schooner Sylph (10) towing schooner Ontario (2) then followed by ship-sloop Madison (24) towing schooner Fair American (2). Madison is the second largest of the American vessels and is112 feet between perpendiculars, making her larger than Wolfe.
After Fair American came the brig Oneida (18), and schooners Governor Tompkins (6), Conquest (3) and Pert (3).
We carried on in this southerly course until one bell in the afternoon watch, when Sir James ordered the squadron to tack in succession. We had speculated on what the Commodore would do as it appeared Chauncey was aiming to cut off the smaller vessels at the rear of our line.
It may be that the American Commodore surmised that we were about the same objective for he then wore ship and had Pike (still towing Asp) on a course to intercept Wolfe to protect the rear of his line. By two bells, the flagships were within cannon shot and Wolfe opened fire.
Another pair of broadsides were exchanged and the very thing that had been feared occurred. Wolfe’s mizzen topmast stays were cut, the unsupported mast pressed forward on to the main topmast and took it down and over the side, splitting the main yard at the same time. With only the headsails and the foremast sails drawing, Wolfe became unmanageable and turned away from the wind of her own accord. It appeared that Chauncey viewed this as the opportunity for victory and again turned Pike downwind to pursue Yeo’s crippled ship.
By now however, the Melville and the Moira had come up and were able to play in their turn upon the Pike. The other lead American vessels were hampered in their movement by having to tow the schooners and while they did add their fire, it proved to be ineffective as our vessels could maneuver out of harm’s way.
I leave you now to commence my plunge into the interior and endeavor to negotiate the goat paths and tracks that pass here for roads.
I wish you the best of good fortune, Sir.
Your Most Humble and Obedient Servant,
A note from Mr. Hurlbut the author:
I used Robert Malcomson's "Lords of the Lakes" as my main source for the action (I'm waiting for a copy of C.H.J. Snider's "In the Wake of the Eighteen-twelvers" right now. He fictionalized the action with dialogue and first person descriptions). I used Mark Lardas' "Great Lakes Warships 1812-15" and "American Light and Medium Frigates 1794-1836" for ships' data. I edited out most of it so as not to bore the audience too much (although a ship's captain would be interested ;-)